Tuesday, April 5, 2011

Why Clare's government politicians don't get on the telly

As a culchie I am regularly incensed by the access that Dublin and Pale based politicians get to the national airwaves. One reason is the ease with which a programme producer can get a  Dublin politician at short notice (and this may explain the season ticket that Richard Boyd Barrett  has to most political programmes).

During the election he must have appeared on 20 programmes. Contrast this with the dearth of  Clare general election candidates onnational  tv or radio panels during the campaign. The only appearance I can recall is a radio debate, that deteriorated into an internal  shouting match, and a profile of John Hillery's campaign in a post election review.
Prime Time and other national shows are 'Clare Free Zones'

There is no doubt that the new  Banner government candidates are still not getting on TV or any  radio airtime on the national airwaves. To date, their appearances on mainstream programmes are effectively non -exsistent and I  suspect this trend will continue.  Our government emissaries to the   Dáil  are not seeking the national stage and don't have views on the national economic crisis / agenda that will get them heard.

Here are my thoughts on the reasons;
  1. The Clare political agenda is locally based and no TD speaks on national matters. Proof of this is the  Clare FM Election debate during the election when  the candidates, despite receiving time to identify their own priorities,  ignored the national economic crisis and didn't address the IMF, Bailout and  balance of payments etc and  spoke about Clare based matters; the local Ennis Hospital and Shannon Airport. This was very revealing.
     
  2. The Clare constituency delivered  three government TD's;  poll topper Pat Breen and Joe Carey of    Fine Gael and rookie Labour TD Michael McNamara. However none of them secured a position in the cabinet or as a minister of state. It is noteworthy that there was zero complaints at local or national about the failure of Clare government TD's to get a ministerial role. Proof that the two Fine Gael men had not built up any real national reputation or expectation of promotion. Hopes seems to rest on the 'geographic reason' It is always likely that the choice of government representations for national TV and radio programmes will  be drawn from the ministerial ranks.
  3. As far as I again see no government TD has spoken in the 31st Dáil on a national matter. Given we           are  going through interesting and critical times surely we should expect our representatives to speak in    the Dáil on these issues?  But its not happening in any meaningful way, if at all. Compare this with the independent Mick Wallace who has spoken every day on  national matters and appeared on numerous programmes, because he has something to say.
  4.  No Clare  government TD is communicating on national matters in a manner to attract attention from outside the constituency.  Looking at their websites  and Twitter updates here's what you get;
  • Labour's Michael McNamara has not updated his website since the election, he 'welcomed' a school building repair programme in Co Clare schools via a press release. MacNamara has not tweeted since the election
  • Pat Breen of Fine Gael's  website has a report on his trip as an EU delegate to Egypt (he spoke in the Dáil on this topic) and 'welcoming'  €99,000 spend on flood relief. His two  Tweets in three months (both directed to me!) were  to advise of his Egyptian sojourn and concerning  custom clearance at Shannon.




  • Joe Carey of Fine Gael  is very active on social media.On his website he highlights the case study of the investment  by the Zagg company in Shannon. He notes the importance of Ireland's 12.5% corporation tax rate in attracting the investment and the benefits of the Mid-West. Clearly this is good work in linking the need for Ireland to retain our 12.5% tax despite opposition from the EU. Mr Carey also was proactive in inviting President Obama to 'stop off' at Shannon during his visit. Other releases, however, fell into the dreaded 'welcoming PR statement category'. However these matters did not get national attention. These included releases regarding    government expenditure on flood relief and school buildings. For me, these fall into the category of seeking to secure credit by association with expenditure that the TD has had nothing do with. But, it seems Carey is trying hardest.
No talk of IMF, Banks or Moriarty  from Clare government men

 So, none of the three Clare govenment TD's are setting out to speak on national matters. It is obvious that anybody putting together a panel for a national TV or radio show will ignore our men as they are silent on the big issues that interest the country. As John Giles says ' you can only judge  what you see'. We are seeing no national work. Have we sent only voting fodder for the huge government majority? Over to you Messrs Carey, Breen and McNamara!

2 comments:

  1. In fact it would appear that Michael McNamara has spoken four times since he was elected, each time on national/international issues. I think he's also been on national telly.

    Also he has updates his website and, even more so, his Facebook page.

    You're perchance not a lazy journo/editor with an axe to griend annonomously online?

    ReplyDelete
  2. When this was written Michael McNamara had not spoken on a national matter.

    (http://www.kildarestreet.com/search/?s=michael+mcnamara)

    Subsequently he has spoken on national matters and updated his website - with 3 postings. A modest enough offering.

    I accept his Facebook is updated frequebtly and was wrong on this point.

    I am not anonymous.

    ReplyDelete